DEMONLORD5000'S PROFILE

I am simply a dangerous tester. Don't believe me? Then give me a game and I'll prove it.

Fear the lord of darkness!

Search

Filter

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

It's possible. I do have an alt theory but it's so bad that I myself don't believe it. Assuming it's muffle, she could of been targeting your list in an attempt to hit the miller in order to make your list look questionable. We'd immediately know who the miller is though if scum killed someone and they flipped scum.

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

Not sure on the psy kill. I can see avoiding the cop given they are hiding as the cop now. It's possibly they didn't go for odd because they thought he might protect himself, and instead decided to go for a random person. I'm assuming they didn't go for me because my powers useless on odd days anyways.

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

I'll go ahead and post a summary of the two so everyone doesn't need to read back.

Muffle - Nailed cave, but this could easily have been a bus strategy in an attempt to escape their horrible situation. In this scenario they were probably hoping fomar was the cop but didn't get lucky. This is the more plausible scenario to me.

Ozzy - If he were scum, the claim traps him in a no win situation while dragging out the game an extra day. This sounds just way more unlikely to me. It's not impossible though since it would be extremely hard for scum to break out of my plan.

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

Forgot to throw down the lynch.

#lynch muffle

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

Alright, our choices today are between muffle and ozzy. I've already given my muffle theory, but I can lynch either way since we still win even with a mislynch today. I'll throw this down for now, but if the majority wants ozzy dead I'm willing to go that route today.

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

Could be, I have a 50/50 shot really since we haven't actively been scumhunting. To me my theory makes more sense than ozzy counterclaiming as scum. It's possible I guess, but if he is scum it doesn't break him out of his situation at all. With 2 cop claims we have statistically solved the game even if we mislynch and hit the real cop first.

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

Alright, I think we basically have this won with only three people on the board as probable scum.

Now that we have a counterclaim I'm actually leaning on muffle being the second scum. Scum counterclaiming at this venture is pointless because it narrows them down even further. I feel like cave and muffle made a gamble on the hopes that fomar was the cop to try to break out of this situation.

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

I don't think anyone suspected me to be the one to propose the game breaking plan. I would say odd should protect muffle tonight. Cave has a 50% chance of being the strongman, and if he is muffle can narrow down second scum even further.

Odd, you really shouldn't have claimed at all because that would make protecting muffle even easier here. I would still say odd should still protect muffle just because he's not 100% confirmed doctor, and moreso like 90% confirmed.

Also: #Lynch Cave

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

I still don't understand why you want psy dead. I'm the one who came up with the plan where we nolynch twice and cop reveals day 3. All he has done is literally go along with my plan.

Feel free to speak up on why you want psy dead since the nolynch period has expired. I find you way more suspicious than I do psy, but I'm going to wait for info to come out before I throw down a lynch.

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

They shouldn't know fomars identity. The only other dead player was emily which I just revealed to be vanilla. I considered withholding the info, but it would take 2 days to even get another read, and if I died scum could attempt shenanigans by claiming to be the town coroner.