THATBENNYGUY'S PROFILE

EDIT:

Replace your list of commonly praised games with this because your bias is showing.

Those were games I pulled from articles and threads when I googled the term "Best RPG Maker games of all-time". I took the names that were regularly cropping up. I haven't even played most of the games on the list I provided. And the list you provided shares a lot of games with the current list. I will examine your list however, to see what I missed.

Updating the list right now...

RMN's Favorite RM Games of All Time List

What Is This?
List your Top 10 Favorite RPG Maker games and I will aggregate the scores and add them to this list.

I've been thinking about doing a "best of RPG Maker games" list for a long time now. I just didn't know how to start. I wanted to know what people believed were the greatest RPG Maker games of all-time, but everyone has different opinions. The question has been asked before, but I want to be able to create a shared list aggregated by everyone's collected views. Plus, there have been many excellent games released since that thread was active, so I have decided to create a new one to attempt to fill that gap.

How it works

• You are to post your Top 10 RPG Maker Games (in your opinion) as a comment in this thread, or as many as you can think of.

• They must be in order of greatness, otherwise I will just assume you listed them in order of greatness.

• Games on your list must be made using any engine made by Enterbrain. The list does not include games made in Wolf Editor, Unity, Game Maker, or other engines made by third parties just because the list might grow very broad, very quickly.

• Free and commercial games are both allowed.

• Episodic games will be judged on a case-by-case basis whether they should be grouped together or not. It will usually be judged by factors such as the length of each episode, and how they are packaged as a whole.

• Votes for your own game won't be counted lol

When users post their top 10 lists, I will use their lists and edit this top post to include the globalized list of all the most highly ranked games. The games will be ranked according to a simple scoring system, which I will explain below.

Scoring system
Each Top 10 list posted in this thread contains 10 entries, which are in order from #1 (the best in the list), to #10 (the worst in the list). The points awarded to the game for the ranking in each persons' list are as follows:

• 1st place -- 10 points

• 2nd place -- 9pts

• 3rd place -- 8pts

• ...

• 10th place -- 1pts

These points will be added to each respective game's total, and the globalized Top RM Games of All Time List will be sorted in order of points the games have earned, from highest to lowest.

RMN's Favorite RM Games of All Time List

1	A Blurred Line	2k	Lys86	2000	100
2	Alter A.I.L.A. Genesis	2k3	Neok	2011	85
3	Star Stealing Prince	VX	Diedrupo+Ronove	2012	72
4=	The Way	2k	LunCasari	2006	69
4=	Hero's Realm	2k3	kentona	2009	69
6	Ara Fell	2k3	BadLuck	Cancelled	64
7	To The Moon	XP	FreeBird Games	2011	58
8	Dhux's Scar	2k	Erilex	2009	49
9	I Miss The Sunrise	VX	Deltree	2012	47
10=	Wine & Roses	VXA	Craze	2012	42
10=	Exit Fate	XP	SCF	2009	42
12	Forever's End	2k3	NicoB	Ongoing	41
13	Homework Salesman	VXA	Diedrupo+Ronove	2013	35
14	Love and War: Act I	2k	Admiral Styles	2009	34
15=	Sunset Over Imdahl	2k	Teo Mathlein	2005	32
15=	The Witch's House	VX	Fummy	2012	32
17=	Ib	2k3	kouri	2012	30
17=	NigSek: A Monster's Tail	2k	Sovan Jedi	2001	30
19	OFF	2k3	Mortis Ghost	2007	29
20=	Space Funeral	2k3	catmitts	2010	28
20=	The Longing Ribbon	2k	Gibmaker	2005	28
22	Romancing Walker	2k	Flare	2001	26
23	Kinetic Cipher (Again)	2k3	The Real Brickroad	Cancelled	25
24=	The Drop	VXA	Deltree	2013	24
24=	Leo & Leah	2k3	Strangeluv	2011	24
24=	Final Fantasy Blackmoon Prophecy	2k3	UPRC	2012	24
27=	Yume Nikki	2k3	Kikiyama	2004	23
27=	Everlong	2k3	DJC	2004	23
29	Kindred Saga	2k	Qheretic	2001	21
30=	Pom Gets Wi-Fi	2k3	Me-Patra	2013	19
30=	Demon Legacy	2k3	Nightblade	2008	19
30=	Notes on the Second Mellynd War	XP/2k3	Eike	2010	19
33=	Phantom Legacy (Redux)	2k3	Nightblade	2013	18
33=	Suzy and freedom	2k3	calunio	2013	18
33=	Legion Saga	2k	Kamau	2001	18
33=	Enelysion	VX	yuna21	2013	18
37=	Set Discrepancy	XP	Gibmaker	Hiatus	17
37=	Aetherion	VX	Anaryu	2011	17
37=	Beautiful Escape: Dungeoneer	2k3	calunio	2010	17
40	The Mirror Lied	XP	Reives	2008	15
41=	Quintessence: The Blighted Venom	XP	Reives	Ongoing	14
41=	Wither	2k3	Rastek	2011	14
41=	Castle Chase	VX	Rachael	2010	14
41=	Balmung Cycle	2k3	Magi	2008	14
45=	Lisa: The First	2k3	Dingaling	2012	13
45=	Aedemphia	2k3	Sylvanor	Ongoing	13
45=	The Reconstruction	XP	Deltree	2009	13
48=	Super Mario RPG: The Seven Sages	2k3	udivision	2010	12
48=	Tales of the Drunken Paladin	VX	Drunken_Paladin	2010	12
50=	The Grumpy Knight	VXA	Fomar0153+Indra	2013	11
50=	Master of the Wind	XP	Artbane+Volrath	2011	11
50=	Desert Nightmare	2k	Kelven	2009	11
50=	Three The Hard Way	2k	iishenron	2003	11
50=	Taut	2k3	TheUnbeholden	2008	11
55=	Spirit In The Mirror	2k	MirroredSpirit	Ongoing	10
55=	Memento Vivere	XP	Diedrupo+Ronove	Hiatus	10
55=	Necropolis	2k3	Jude	Cancelled	10
55=	Touhou: Wandering Souls	VX	Estheone	2013	10
55=	Menagerie	VXA	BizarreMonkey	2013	10
55=	Manifest	VX	sbethune81	2011	10
55=	Vacant Sky: Contention	XP	Sailerius	2009	10
55=	Clock of Atonement	2k	daigo	2007	10
55=	Backstage	2k3	Max McGee	2005	10
55=	Seraphic Blue	2k	Tempura	2004	10
55=	Angels of Exodus	2k3	Illustrious	2000	10
55=	Corpse Party	95	Team GrisGris	1996	10
55=	Final Fantasy Endless Nova	2k	Delita Hyral X	2002	10
55=	Chimera Report	2k	D-Guy	2009	10
55=	Memories of Mana	XP	Moghunter	?	10
70=	Crystalis: Sonata of the Far-Away Sky	2k3	Avee	Ongoing	9
70=	Esper Wing Chronicle	VXA	ChaosAvian	2012	9
70=	Fleuret Blanc.	XP	Merlandese	2012	9
70=	Dragon Fantasy	2k	Ephiam	2010	9
70=	The Tiamat Sacrament	2k3	Drakonais	2010	9
70=	.flow	2k	lol	2009	9
70=	Nocturne Rebirth	XP	Cogwheel	2009	9
70=	Schuld	2k3	Kelven	2008	9
70=	Palette	95	Finger Puppet	1998	9
70=	Ill Will	VX	LouisCyphre+Archeia_Nessiah+Happy	2012	9
80=	Sore Losers: Riot Grrrl	2k3	Sated	Ongoing	8
80=	Alter A.I.L.A. Variant	2k3	Neok	Cancelled	8
80=	Cell Chamber	XP	Calibre	Cancelled	8
80=	I'm Scared of Girls	2k3	CARRIONBLUE	2011	8
80=	Lain's Horrible Adventure	VX	Nephil V	2011	8
80=	Legionwood	VX	Dark Gaia	2011	8
80=	Fable of Heroes	2k	Dustsoft	2010	8
80=	Visions & Voices	VX	Craze+Karsuman	2009	8
80=	The Frozen World	2k	Lys86	2003	8
80=	Deus Cards	2k	Watermark	2002	8
80=	Everlasting Journey	2k3	PepsiOtaku	2014	8
91	Paranormal Syndrome	2k	Yuuyami no Kisetsu	2013	7
91	Rust and Blood	VXA	SnowOwl	2013	7
91	Lunar Wish: Orbs of Fate	VXA	Lustermx	2013	7
91	Gingiva	XP	myformerselves	2013	7
91	Intelligence	VX	BizarreMonkey	2011	7
91	SkyE	VX	Anaryu+Krisanna	2008	7
91	Spinel's Core	XP	Regimos	2008	7
91	Whisper Of A Rose	XP	Rose Portal Games	2008	7
91	Professor McLogic Saves The Day	2k3	Gibmaker	2008	7
91	Clouded Heart	2k	karlmh	2006	7
91	Destiny's Call Complete	?	?	?	7
91	Middens	XP	myformerselves	2012	7
91	Happy Birthday	VXA	TearsOfNightfall	2012	7
104=	Dragon Quest: Legacy of the Lost	VX	Orias_Obderhode	2013	6
104=	Reincarnation: Dawn Of War	VXA	Hirei	2013	6
104=	Final Fallacy	2k3	Spoonybard	2011	6
104=	Cognitive Dissonance	2k3	otherhand	2008	6
104=	Eternal Eden	XP	Elder	2008	6
104=	Ahriman's Prophecy	2k	Amanda Fitch	2004	6
104=	Iron Gaia	2k	Max McGee	2004	6
104=	Jay's Journey	2k	HeroicJay	2002	6
112=	Heartache 101 ~Sour Into Sweet~	XP	flowerthief	2011	5
112=	Starless Umbra	2k3	dragonheartman	Ongoing	5
112=	X-Noir	VXA	Artbane+Volrath	Ongoing	5
112=	Shichimenchouken	2k	FelixTrapper	?	5
112=	Dungeons	XP	?	?	5
112=	The Chronicles of Haledos	2k	?	?	5
112=	- fey -	2k3	Ashes of Emerald	2013	5
112=	Miserere	XP	SnowOwl	2012	5
112=	Edifice	VX	Craze	2011	5
112=	Pokemon Reborn	XP	Amethyst	2010	5
112=	Tale of Exile	2k3	Lastturn	2009	5
112=	Last Scenario	XP	SCF	2007	5
112=	Vampires Dawn 2	2k3	Marlex	2005	5
112=	Aurora's Tear	2k	PhoenixDown	2001	5
112=	Final Fantasy Zero	XP	Petros	2009	5
112=	Legend of the Philosopher's Stone	2k3	xxNemesis29xx+Litearc	2005	5
112=	Standstill Girl	2k	Sky Scraper Project	?	5
112=	Dead Moon Night	VXA	Fomar0153+Indra	2012	5
130=	Subject	VXA	Indra	2013	4
130=	Irisu Syndrome	?	?	?	4
130=	Crossbone	2k	weremole	?	4
130=	The Legacy of Zalgoth	XP	?	?	4
130=	Robocks	2k	?	?	4
130=	Darkblood Chronicles	VXA	doriantoki	2013	4
130=	A Butterfly's Song	?	Natrius	2003	4
130=	The Blue Contestant	2k	Lys86	2003	4
130=	Until My Finest Hour	?	BloodRose	2002	4
130=	Onyx	2k	Yeaster	2008	4
140=	Castlevania: Sonata in Red	2k3	Hardle	Ongoing	3
140=	Lands of Lunori	2k3	Jenna	Cancelled	3
140=	Wilfred the Hero, Part 1	2k3	brandonabley	Cancelled	3
140=	Tyrant God Saga: Altered Perception	2k	brandonabley	?	3
140=	Push	2k3	?	?	3
140=	Crepusculum	XP	?	?	3
140=	Phylomortis 2	2k	RPG Advocate	?	3
140=	ovnogesl (v3)	VX	centridus	2013	3
140=	Labyrinthine Dreams	VXA	Artbane+Volrath	2013	3
140=	Pro Whaling 2012	VX	Proto	2011	3
140=	Chrono Alter	2k3	Lance VII	2010	3
140=	Deadly Sin 2	VX	harmonic	2010	3
140=	Outlaw City	XP	Anaryu	2010	3
140=	Land of Dreams	2k	Darkflamewolf	2010	3
140=	Embric of Wulfhammer's Castle	2k3	Saint Bomber	2009	3
140=	Speak No Evil	2k3	LouisCyphre	2009	3
140=	Avarice	VX	Anaryu+Solitayre	2009	3
140=	Pirates	2k3	?	?	3
140=	The Black Rose	XP	DarkHalo	2012	3
159=	Utopian Chaos	XP	?	?	2
159=	The Kyrent Project	2k	?	?	2
159=	Lunacity	VXA	Ocean+Hirei	2013	2
159=	Quest Fantasy	VXA	Leet	2013	2
159=	ReEvolution	VXA	SorceressKrysty	2013	2
159=	Skinwalker	VXA	SnowOwl	2013	2
159=	Sweet Lily Dreams	XP	Rose Portal Games	2011	2
159=	Cyber Factor	2k3	Leric	2004	2
159=	Laxius Power	2k	Indinera Falls	2001	2
159=	Dark Soul	2k	El Diablo	2001	2
159=	Spike Lee's The Twilight Zone	2k3	Strangeluv	2010	2
159=	Aveyond 1: Rhen's Quest	XP	Amaranth Games	2009	2
171=	Profit Motive	VX	kulimar	Hiatus	1
171=	Reality Breakdown	2k	kamain	?	1
171=	Akasha Seal	XP	?	?	1
171=	Safety: Life Is A Maze	2k3	CARRIONBLUE	2013	1
171=	Hero: The Princess Pursuit	VXA	limsoonchiong	2013	1
171=	The Shoe's On The Other Foot	VXA	kukenstragames	2013	1
171=	Shukumei Star	2k3	crthibodeau	2011	1
171=	Sore Losers	2k	Sated	2010	1
171=	Legends of Illarion	2k3	Dyluck	2009	1
171=	Retsu Arashi Psychic Storm	2k	Skyman07	2005	1
171=	The Book Of Three	2k	Lys86	2001	1
171=	Redmoon Saga	2k	?	2000	1
171=	Dooms 4	?	MISTER BIG T	?	1

Latest user list included: Neok 07/15/2014 08:51 PM

Name: St. Vertwick Cathedral
Type: Church
Biome: Wastelands

Notable features: The area was ransacked a little while ago, but a few people still sometimes camp in the dusty area surrounding the church.

Description: The St. Vertwick Cathedral is a small abandoned cathedral in the wastelands. Long ago, there was a holy war in the region, which caused the evil lord Drovai to curse the Church for the religions it had been teaching the local people. Citizens then ransacked the church, overturning tables, chairs and generally leaving the place abandoned.

It is said that within the Cathedral lies a holy Druid's Relic that enables secret passages.

~~~

On that note, how's progress on this game going? I'm interested to see if you are still waiting on help for locations, or what is needed to further progress.

Me 3! Congrats to the winrars though

I really like that you're doing the whole game in this style now.