CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK'S PROFILE

CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142

Search

Filter

Mafia: Round 2 (Lounge/Sign-ups)



Honestly, it probably would not have affected the flow of the game too much, I think that's just a good rule to abide by.

Mafia: Round 2 (Lounge/Sign-ups)

author=rabitZ
stuff

it's probably bad form to make posts like this in the lounge thread, just because you're still in the game.

it's why i haven't responded to anyone who insists that lynching despite was a bad idea

Mafia: Round 2 (Lounge/Sign-ups)

happy and i were killed for being too good at mafia

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

I meant day before, also. don't read my posts nobody read my posts

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

Because it's a lot easier for mafia to wifom in the night. Like, if rabitz died, people might say "oh it was cave dog cave dog murdered the rabit like all dogs do" but that really doesn't tell us anything because mafia frame people all the time and wifom all the time. a lot more information is generated from a day lynch because you have everyone's posts and arguments about why that person should/should not be lynched as opposed to random dude x dying in the night, someone who may have not even been targeted the night before.
Does that answer your question? *tips hat*

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

aaaaa its not a bandwagon that is on despite

having two town or one scum one town dead day two with information to go on is a far better situation than having one town dead d2 and no information to go on. Would you mind explaining your assertion that Despite is absolutely not a cannibal?

it would also be helpful if people could explain who they find of suspicious instead of saying "yeorp....mighty suspicious around these parts." the former gives us more information to go on later while the later just allows you to say "yeah, i knew he was bad" when someone flips scum.

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

author=rabitZ
Want to know how I feel?
I feel that despite doesn't care about wheter he lives or dies, and I don't think that is very useful in the long run.
If it was up to me alone, I'd lynch him (at least if he gave a really good explanation first). I can understand the reasoning behind his lynching giving good information to proceed on.
Of course, at this point people would call me a bandwagoner, but I guess that can't be avoided?


Being afraid to cast a vote for someone for fear of being called the horrible epithet "bandwagon man" is pretty weird on the first day of a mafia game where it takes nine people to lynch. Voting against what you think is the right choice because you don't want to seem suspicious is the most suspicious thing.

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

no, that's your phrasing. I was quoting you. If you wanted to vote to get a reaction out of me, okay, but unfortunately you phrased your post in maybe the scummiest way possible. As for not being able to decide if we should lynch or not lynch, again, why are you completely excluding yourself from that decision? "Well, looks like town is gonna do whatever. Ho Hum"

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

"Huh, well, I'm going to vote for this guy, But I certainly would want to be appearing to side with THE TOWNIES if it's clear that this won't work."

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

In what way is lynching a person contributing to the town's wellbeing a safe choice.

i don't care so much about the vote on me because i really doubt i'm gonna get lynched today, but aside from that, your post is a total-non constribution. there is literally nothing substantial in it, you point out that there is a lot of discussion without adding to it, and say you will change your vote if "the townies" (very suspicious phrasing, by the way) think it is in our best interest.